Introduction to Creative Commons Licenses for NFTs- Crypto.ex

Introduction to Creative Commons Licenses for NFTs

Cryptocurrencies face legal challenges ranging from the tax treatment of decentralized finance (DeFi) rewards to what constitutes tokenized securities during an initial coin offering (ICO). For non-fungible tokens (NFTs), copyright issues have become the most important legal battleground as artists put their rights at stake.

For example, the popular Creative Commons (CC) licenses allow sharing of an artist's work with attribution. But suppose someone creates and sells a limited-edition NFT of that work without the original artist's permission. As long as they provide attribution, they will comply with the CC license, but it's easy to see why this could cause problems.

Let's take a look at how Creative Commons licenses work and how they can work in the world of NFTs.

The Creative Commons license allows anyone to create and share creative works, but what does this mean for creating NFTs?

Just a Quick Introduction

NFTs, also known as non-fungible tokens, are special tokens created on a blockchain. Particularly, almost all NFTs are Ethereum blockchain-based ERC721 tokens. These tokens provide information on a digital object that is permanently added to the blockchain as metadata. From straightforward digital painting to sophisticated play-to-earn games, they power everything.

An multinational network and nonprofit organisation called Creative Commons attempts to increase the variety of creative works available for use and sharing. For the benefit of consumers and other creators, the organisation primarily develops and manages free-to-use licences that allow writers to specify whose rights they reserve and renounce.

Naturally, Creative Commons isn't the only licence that artists utilise to safeguard their creations. All works are the property of their creators, who may choose to commercialise and protect their creations by using public domain or commercial licences. For instance, rather than using CC licenses, many digital artists use GNU or Copyleft licenses.

NFTs and Creative Commons

While producing limited-edition NFTs, many artists opt to make their work available to the public under a Creative Commons licence. There is minimal debate about using limited-edition NFTs to monetize the original artist's work because they are the ones issuing the NFT. According to Creative Commons, there is no conflict in an artist doing so.

The moment another person mints an NFT of the original artist's work, though, issues arise. For instance, the Global Art Museum sponsored a PR stunt in which it claimed to tokenize masterpieces in the public domain and sell them on OpenSea. Before it was realised that the action was a hoax, the move prompted a swift and ferocious outcry from the art world.

Legal experts generally concur that minting an NFT of a work in the public domain is offensive but is not copyfraud. After all, the party issuing an NFT merely mints some information and enters it into the Ethereum blockchain using a public domain picture. No ownership claims are made, and the "unique" token isn't even a replica of the original work.

What About Other Licenses?

The claim that NFTs are merely minting information and not directly replicating any works of art may have much wider ramifications. For instance, despite the fact that Creative Commons licences explicitly enable reuse, people who mint NFTs of copyright works may contend that they are only adding metadata to the blockchain and not actually duplicating any artwork.

Naturally, people who are minting NFTs can encounter issues if they assert bogus ownership. For instance, it may violate the moral right of attribution if someone encoded information asserting ownership of the NFT's contents. Additionally, these infractions may pave the way for future legal actions brought by an artist against the NFT minter.

These difficulties might result in much trickier issues. Consider the scenario where NFTs purport to be the work of the elusive artist Banksy. Without disclosing the artist's name, there would be no way to confirm the accuracy of the work or pursue the real creator. For creative groups, these dynamics provide a challenging issue.

Other Difficulties & Possibilities.

The selling of NFTs also presents unique copyright difficulties. For example, the terms and conditions of Bored Apes declare that NFT buyers fully own the underlying Bored Ape, the Art. Secondary sales, however, may not effectively transfer the copyright to the purchaser if they don't include written and signed consents to transfer.

These issues could deteriorate in programmes that don't explicitly state copyrights. For instance, CryptoPunks had implicit copyright conditions that put everyone at danger of legal trouble. Although Larva Labs sought to retrospectively add a copyright licence, legal experts are divided on the legality of such a move.

NFTs provide a number of issues for copyright law, but they also present some special potential for artists. The underlying smart contracts in NFTs can provide special functionalities, such artist royalties on secondary sales, allowing creators to capture extra value in addition to selling their work through one-off sales.

The Conclusion

The use of non-fungible tokens makes a number of legal defences against copyright laws possible. Public domain works and Creative Commons licences have gained attention, but these issues are also affecting commercial rights and copyright law. In the end, they might not have a clear answer until the courts have a say.

Copyright concerns are, of course, just the beginning of the legal difficulties facing the developing crypto business. When it comes to safeguarding their assets or paying taxes, developers, collectors, investors, and users are in a difficult position because the IRS, SEC, and other governmental agencies continue to battle to regulate emerging digital inventions.

If you trade digital assets, ZenLedger can assist you with gathering transactions from various exchanges, calculating capital gains or losses, and producing the annual tax documents you require. The tool may also assist you in tracking your assets, locating chances to realise tax losses, and lowering your year-end tax obligations.